Monday, July 21, 2008 Dumaguing: Athletic benefit of growth hormone: Is it all in the mind? By Dr. Victor Dumaguing To Your Health
IF ATHLETES believe they are using a performing-enhancing drug, they may think their athletic performance improves, and in some men, it can, even if they are actually taking a dummy drug, a new study has found. Results of the study were presented at The Endocrine Society's 90th Annual Meeting in San Francisco.
This so-called placebo was greater in male recreational athletes than in females, said lead author Jennifer Hansen, RN, a nurse researcher at the Garvan Institute for Medical Research in Sydney, Australia. In a study of growth hormones, the authors tested whether the power of the mind affects physical performance.
"Athletes are doping with growth hormone to improve sporting performance despite any evidence it actually improves performance," Hansen said. "Therefore, we wanted to know if any improvement in performance is due just to the athletes' belief that they are taking an agent that enhances performance, rather than to the agent itself."
Sixty-four young adult recreational athletes randomly received either growth hormone -- a substance banned in sports -- or an inactive substance (placebo) for eight weeks. Neither the athletes who volunteered for the study nor the investigators knew which substance the athletes received.
At the end of the study, the researchers asked the athletes to guess which agent they had taken and to say if they thought their sporting performance had changed. Then they tested the athletes on physical performance tests of endurance, strength, power, and sprint capacity.
Men were much more likely than women to think they had received growth hormone. Regardless of sex, athletes who took the dummy drug but believed they were on growth hormone ("incorrect guessers") thought their performance improved and actually had some improvement in all measures of performance. However, jump height (power) was the only test that showed a significantly greater improvement among the incorrect guessers, according to Hansen.
"The results of this study suggest that the placebo effect may be responsible, at least in part, for the perceived athletic benefit of doping with growth hormone for some people," Hansen said.
