Day 23 Highlights
Jan. 16, 2001
-
The Erap Muslim Youth Foundation does not exist, prosecution
witness lawyer Oswaldo Santos told the impeachment court.
The address given by the foundation to SEC is occupied by
the law office of Presidential Legal Adviser Edward Serapio,
he said. Serapio is one of the incorporators of the foundation
while former Equitable PCI Bank chair George Go is the treasurer.
-
The prosecution argued that the second envelope, which reportedly
contained details of the P3.3-billion account of Jose Velarde
with Equitable PCI Bank, should be opened if the prosecution
is to prove its case against the President.
-
The defense argued that the document sought to be opened is
immaterial and irrelevant to the case and that the impeachment
court has no jurisdiction over it.
-
The
impeachment court voted 10-11 against the opening of the sealed
envelope.
-
Senator-Judge
Aquilino Pimentel Jr. resigned as Senate president. Lawyer
Lutgardo Barbo also resigned as Senate secretary. Pimentel
voted in favor of opening the second bank envelope.
Day
22 Highlights
Jan. 15, 2001
-
Former
SEC chairman Perfecto Yasay told the impeachment court that
President Estrada offered to fund his campaign if he decides
to run as congressional representative of Davao. Yasay said
the offer was made to persuade him to resign from office.
-
He
also said that the BW scandal may have a connection to the disappearance
of PR man Bubby Dacer, who, he claimed, knew something about
the gaming firm.
-
The
defense panel presented video footage of separate interviews
with Yasay to stress that Yasay denied more than four times
that he was pressured by Estrada to clear Dante Tan and BW Resources.
-
The
prosecution moved to withdraw Anton Prieto as witness, a move
that will lead to the striking off from the impeachment court
records of everything that he has said.
Day
21 highlights
Jan. 11, 2001
-
Ex-finance secretary Edgardo Espiritu told the impeachment tribunal
President Estrada ordered the Philippine National Bank (PNB)
president to grant a P600-million loan to gambling firm BW Resources.
Espiritu was quoting the PNB president who reported the matter
to him. The defense declared the statement as hearsay, but Chief
Justice Hilario Davide ruled that it remain on record.
-
Senator-Judge Renato Cayetano received a bullet and a letter
threatening his life.
-
Espiritu said Executive Secretary Edgardo Angara and three presidential
friends tried to dissuade him from testifying yesterday, using
a legal case against his son as a carrot stick.
-
The former cabinet official also revealed he saw smugglers attending
social functions at Malacañang and that he suspected
that the Economic Intelligence and Investigation Bureau was
abolished because the agency caught someone close to the President.
-
Former SEC Chairman Perfecto Yasay Jr. claimed that he was asked
by President Estrada to clear Dante Tan of the BW insider trading
scandal.
-
Yasay confirmed that Eva Lesbo, whom Tan alleged as the one
who received the 200,000 shares of BW stocks as bribe, is a
member of his church.
DAY
20 highlights
Jan. 11, 2001
-
Senator-Judges
arrived at a consensus that the allegation made by Senator-Judge
Renato Cayetano, accusing President Estrada of intervening in
favor of the accused in the Vizconde murder case, will not be
discussed in the impeachment trial but will be referred instead
to the Senate. The privilege speech of Cayetano, though, will
remain in the impeachment trial records.
-
Former
Philippine Stock Exchange (PSE) president Jose Luis Yulo admitted
that the President did not categorically tell him to exonerate
friend Dante Tan of insider trading charges.
-
Yulo
told the impeachment court that he considered Estrada a friend
and this was one of the reasons that made him believe that the
President should resign. He said if Estrada had resigned, he
would have been spared the indignities of an impeachment and
his resignation would have even been considered an act of courage.
-
Daily
Tribune business editor Emeterio Perez testified he was with
then SEC chairman Perfecto Yasay Jr. when Estrada called on
Nov. 19, 1999. He said he heard Yasay tell the President that
an investigation should be done on Dante Tan, in relation to
insider trading allegations.
-
33rd
prosecution witness Edgardo Espiritu told the court that Estrada
did not only intervene in the BW stock scam to save presidential
friend Dante Tan but also to protect Estrada's shares of stocks
with the BW Resources Corp.
-
34th
witness Perfecto Yasay Jr. claimed he was pressured by Malacañang
into reversing a SEC decision against a project that would benefit
Estrada's mistress Guia Gomez.
Day
19 Highlights
Jan. 10, 2001
- Senator-Judge
Renato Cayetano, in an emotional privilege speech, accused President
Estrada of having intervened in behalf of the accused in the Vizconde
murder case. Cayetano was reacting to what he referred to as "black
propaganda," meant to influence his judgment as senator-judge
in the impeachment trial against Estrada. He denied allegation
made by presidential pal Dante Tan that he (Cayetano) earned P70
million from shares in gambling firm BW Resources.
- Senator-Judge
Rodolfo Biazon called the attention of the impeachment court to
a mock trial aired on the radio, discussing the testimonies and
evidence used in the trial. He said the radio program made a mockery
of the trial proceedings.
- Prosecution
witness Ruben Almadro admitted that while the Philippine Stock
Exchange (PSE) compliance and surveillance group found Dante Tan
liable of insider trading, the investigation report was not acted
on by higher authority.
- Senator-Judge
Franklin Drilon asked the court to issue an order directing lawyer-brothers
Sigfrid and Raymond Fortun and lawyer Alfredo Villamor, all of
the defense panel, to show cause why they should not be cited
for contempt. Drilon reasoned that the lawyers wasted the court's
time and even misled it because the Delia Rajas that was presented
to the court was not the same Rajas that withdrew money from the
tobacco excise tax in 1998.
- Senator-Judge
Nikki Coseteng manifested that she may also do the same for Representative-Prosecutor
Oscar Gonzales. She stuck to her stand that the prosecutor insinuated
that she was not telling the truth about former PSE head Jose
Luis Yulo's presence in the courtroom while Almadro was giving
his testimony.
- Yulo, the
prosecution's 30th witness, testified that he was set up to meet
with Dante Tan, after a meeting with former SEC chairman Perfecto
Yasay to discuss BW Resources. He also corroborated most of what
Almadro told the impeachment court.
Day
18 Highlights
Jan. 9, 2001
- Senator-Judge
Miriam Defensor-Santiago withdraws motion to reconsider ban on
trial spectators Volunteers Against Crime and Corruption president
Dante Jimenez, Rosanna Fores and Bettina Aboitiz.
- None of the
senator-judges made any manifestation after Santiago reiterated
she "will vehemently oppose" any motion for reconsideration
of the ban.
- Prosecution
witness Victor Lim, vice president of Citibank, confirmed that
a Metrobank check of P8.4 million was deposited in the account
of First Lady Loi Ejercito.
- In view of
the deposit's amount, the bank attempted to conduct a "friendly
query" but the First Lady was not available to answer questions.
Bank accepted the deposit anyway because the depositor is the
First Lady.
- Chief Justice
Hilario Davide Jr. denies motion to quash filed by the defense
against summons on Ruben Almagro, Mary Ann Corpuz and Jose Luis
Yulo of the Philippine Stock Exchange. Davide also denied motion
to quash summons on BIR officials.
- Prosecution
panel urged the Senate impeachment court to issue a subpoena ad
testificandum et duces tecum to Former Executive Secretary Ronaldo
Zamora in connection with the Executive Order issued by the President
to the Bureau of Custom for the transfer of all the seized articles
by the agency.
Day
17 Highlights
Jan. 8, 2001
-
Defense
asked prosecution witness Caridad Rodenas, cashier of LBP-Shaw
Blvd. branch, to identify Delia Rajas, insisting that she
was on the gallery watching the proceedings.
- Rodenas assured
the impeachment tribunal she would recognize the Rajas who came
to her bank on Aug. 28, 1998, provided she did not change her
appearance.
- The Land
Bank cashier went around the gallery but said the Delia Rajas
who opened an account in Land Bank was not present.
- Defense called
to the stand Delia Rajas, who cooks for the household of Catalina
Ang, mother of Charlie "Atong" Ang but she is not the
same Delia Rajas who opened an account with Land Bank of the Philippines
(LBP) Shaw Blvd. branch with a P50-million deposit.
- The Delia
Rajas presented by the defense was the Rajas referred to in the
SSS application form presented as one of the prosecution's exhibits.
- Defense lawyer
Siegfrid Fortun admitted they knew Rajas is not the same one in
the ID photos submitted to LBP Shaw Blvd.
- Several senator-judges
were irked over Fortun's actions, saying it was "unfair,
misleading and a dirty trick," which can be a ground for
the court to cite the lawyer in contempt.
- Rodenas confirmed
that the Eleuterio Tan, who appeared with Rajas and Alma Alfaro
on Aug. 28, 1998 to open an account at the bank, is the same one
whose photo appeared in the LTO records (computer-generated photograph
of Victor Jose Tan Uy) and in the two IDs for Solid Builders Center
and ET Enterprises Inc.
- Ferdinand
Sales of the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) appeared to
prove that the incorporation of the Prominent Consultants and
Management came later than the award to operate the Bingo-2 Ball.
- Cebu Rep.
Clavel Asas-Martinez conducted a short direct examination on Sales,
after the defense stipulated to the SEC documents presented as
evidence.
- Victor Lim,
Citibank vice president, appeared to testify on the bank account
of First Lady Loi Ejercito. The prosecution said the P8-million
check issued by Gov. Chavit Singson came from jueteng.
Day
16 Highlights
Jan. 5, 2001
-
Prosecution presents bank documents showing how a total
of P170 million was transferred from Land Bank of the Philippines-Vigan
to Land Bank of the Philippines-Shaw Blvd., broken down
in various deposits to the accounts of Eleuterio Tan, Delia
Rajas, Alma Alfaro and Lucio Severio.
-
Rajas' SSS records show that she was connected with Power
Management Consultancy Inc., where Charlie "Atong"
Ang is an officer.
-
The photo on an identification card of Eleuterio Tan, accountant,
was the same as that on the driver's license of Victor Jose
Tan Uy.
-
Senator-judge Miriam Defensor-Santiago thanked the Supreme
Court for issuing a temporary restraining order on Akbayan
for picketing her residence
-
Defense refused to accept as part of the evidence, the Citibank
account of First Lady Loi Ejercito opened with an P8-million
check issued by Ilocos Sur Gov. Luis Singson
-
An official of the Land Bank of the Philippines - Shaw boulevard
branch confirmed that she knew Alma Alfaro even before the
latter opened an account which served as a funnel for the
P40-million fund from Ilocos Sur
Day
15 Highlights
Jan. 4, 2001
-
Witness Ma. Jazmin Banal told the impeachment tribunal she
was never aware of the identity of the owners of two firms,
Alexie Equities and Pio Holdings, which the prosecution
has claimed to be syndicates to funnel jueteng money to
President Estrada. (She had been named as one of the incorporators,
although she said she was also made to sign a blank deed
of assignment.)
- A furious
Senator-judge Miriam Defensor Santiago requested that three persons,
whom she said stood and looked at her "provocatively"
while Senator-judge Raul Roco questioned Banal, be held in contempt
of court.
- Dante Jimenez
of the Volunteers Against Crime and Corruption, Rosanna Fores
and Bettina Araneta-Aboitiz, whom Santiago accused of allegedly
violating court rules on decorum, were permanently barred from
attending the impeachment trial. They apparently were not given
a chance to explain.
- Lawyer Emilia
Padua, head of the Pagcor entertainment and bingo department,
testified that the gaming board hired Prominent Marketing Consulting
Group represented by Charlie "Atong" Ang.
- Padua said
Prominent was hired to identify sales agents of Bingo 2 Ball games
and collect from them. Prominent Marketing did not have a contract
with Pagcor, but the agreement was that the firm gets two percent
of the total sales of Bingo 2 Ball games.
- Padua admitted
that Bingo 2 Ball, whose trial operations got the verbal clearance
of President Estrada, was meant to "legalize" jueteng
and that some sales agents of the new game were jueteng operators.
- Senator-judge
John Osmeña called the attention of Chief Justice Hilario
Davide to a microphone he found behind him. The microphone belonged
to GMA 7 and the TV station's cameraman was told to explain, under
oath, the presence of the device. The microphone was later removed.
Day
14 Highlights
Jan. 3, 2001
-
Ilocos Sur Gov. Luis "Chavit" Singson admitted
he falsified documents to make it appear that government
funds were used to purchase equipment for a tobacco curing
farm. But he said it was all under President Estrada's instructions.
- Singson
said he knew from the start that he was committing a crime when
he covered up for the President.
- Singson
said presidential pal Jojo Uy, a businessman, could enter Malacañang
without undergoing security check. The governor said Uy, who has
businesses in Cebu, is "very powerful and influential"
when it comes to the President. Uy allegedly cashed a total of
P90 million in August 1998. This amount, Singson said, formed
part of the P130-million fund that was given to Estrada from out
of the Ilocos Sur share of the tobacco excise taxes.
- Singson
and Estrada's chief lawyer Estelito Mendoza traded testy remarks
but the governor was not shaken from his testimony that collections,
mostly in P1,000 bills, were either deposited in banks or handed
over to the President over a two-year period.
Day
13 highlights
Jan. 2, 2001
-
Lawyers
of President Estrada refused to cross-examine prosecution
witness Clarissa Ocampo. They considered her testimony to
be immaterial to the articles of impeachment.
- Ocampo said
lawyer Manuel Curato asked her to go to Malacañang and
that she assumed she would probably meet the President.
- Ocampo said
the investment agreement was confidential, referred to only as
C-163 and not by the account name. She said she pulled out a lot
of the documents since the President didn't want to sign too many
papers.
- Ocampo again
said she had no idea of the signatory and under what name the
investment management agreement would be signed, and that she
found out that it would be the President only an hour before the
actual signing.
- Ocampo said
she is testifying because: she saw the President sign as Jose
Velarde; Chua remembered that she was there and so she was afraid
for her life and security of her family; there was an instruction
from Equitable PCIBank chair and presidential friend George Go
to prepare another set of investment management documents. This
second set was to be made for Jaime Dichaves. The signing was
on Dec. 11, and it was done at the office of lawyer Estelito Mendoza
(defense counsel), to transfer from Jose Velarde to Jaime Dichaves.
- Ocampo said
Dichaves signed the second set of documents under his name, but
the investment management documents were not implemented because
the principal was really Jose Velarde, and they needed a directional
letter from Velarde which never came. She said this happened on
Dec. 13 last year.
- Ocampo said
Chua told her that he had already brought the investment management
matter to the senior management of the bank, and reminded her
that she should "protect the President."
- Defense
counsel Estelito Mendoza said he "had no participation at
all in regard to this trust account." He said: "As far
as my appearance in this case, I can withdraw anytime, but I have
a function and duty to perform. If the President will allow it,
I am prepared to withdraw from this case, however I am not one
to withdraw from a case. But let it be clear that I am not withdrawing
from the case on the basis of allegations of impropriety."
- Manuel Curato
testified that on Feb. 4, 2000 he was at Malacañang with
Clarissa Ocampo to have documents signed by President Estrada.
He said Aprodicio Laquian and Fernando Chua were also there. Curato
said the President signed the documents in their presence.
Day
12 highlights
Dec. 22, 2000
-
Witness Clarissa Ocampo said President Estrada signed a
P500-million trust account under the name Jose Velarde in
her presence and that of the other witnesses
-
Ocampo,
senior vice president and trust officer of the Equitable
PCI bank, said that Estrada also signed in as Jose Velarde
in the specimen signature card and that she was shocked
over the incident and thus she did not authenticate the
document
-
Eleuterio
Tan, who was earlier identified as among those who encashed
a managers check from out of the P200-million Ilocos Sur
share of the tobacco excise tax, was traced to be Victor
Jose Tan Uy of 2041 MJ Cuenco ave., Cebu City
-
About
three hours was spent arguing on whether or not to allow
witness Ocampo to testify. Under the impeachment rules,
she could not testify yet as Impeachment Article 1 has not
yet been concluded yet
-
Ocampo's
testimonies was vigorously opposed by the defense counsels
as almost prosecution question was objected to by Atty.
Jose Flaminiano
-
Another
witness, Manuel Curato, who reportedly witnessed the signing
of President Estrada as Jose Velarde went to the Senate
yesterday to testify. He was not able to do so for lack
of time
Day
11 highlights
Dec. 21, 2000
-
Yolando
Ricaforte walked into Equitable PCI Bank Diliman to open
an account with an initial deposit of P500,000 cash, said
branch manager Rosario Bautista. A few days later, she deposited
two checks for P35 million each or a total of P70 million
drawn by William Gatchalian, a friend of President Estrada.
-
Ricaforte
had several accounts in six Equitable PCI Bank branches.
-
She
requested for cashier's checks worth millions of pesos from
the different Equitable PCI branches from March to April
this year.
-
Chief
Justice Hilario Davide Jr. chided the prosecution for issuing
a statement that the bank account documents in a sealed
envelope, which were in the custody of the Senate secretary,
were "tampered". He reminded lawyers of their
duties as officials of the court in making statements to
the media.
-
Prosecutor
Oscar Moreno told the impeachment tribunal that he never
insinuated that tampering, if there was any, was done while
the bank documents were in the custody of the Senate.
-
Of
the five witnesses presented yesterday by the prosecution,
all Equitable PCI bank managers, the defense panel cross-examined
only one.
Day
10 highlights
Dec. 20, 2000
-
The sealed envelope containing records of the Jose Valhalla
account was opened before the impeachment court.
-
Prosecution
lawyers claimed that the entry on a P142-million transaction
has erasures.
-
Reporters
Christine Herrera and Carlito Pablo of the Philippine Daily
Inquirer (PDI) confirmed that their spouses worked for Senator
Judge Loren Legarda - Leviste and Rep. Roilo Golez, respectively
during a hearing for contempt.
-
PNP
Chief Panfilo Lacson denied that the Presidential Anti-Organized
Crime Task Force is involved in the surveillance or monitoring
of opposition senators and the rest of the 100 people identified
by a news article.
-
PLDT
employe Flodina Pasamba, Lacson claimed, is the one who
gave the PDI "source" copies of the "call-detail
records."
-
12th
witness Rufo Colayco claimed he was called by President
Estrada to Malacanang for a meeting on the establishment
of a Fontainebleu casino inside the Clark Development Park.
-
He
also claimed the President had asked for the 35 percent
share in the income of the casino.
-
Lucio
Co, operator of the largest duty-free shop in the country,
reportedly gained ownership of the Fontana Resort.
Day
9 highlights
Dec 19, 2000
-
2
reporters explain details on the surveillance conducted
allegedly by PAOCTF on impeachment prosecutors, judges and
some witnesses.
- PNP Chief
Panfilo Lacson finds the testimonies "incredible, ludicrous"
and dares source to take the witness stand in fairness to the
people accused.
- Rep. Clavel
Asas-Martinez says she was quoted out of context by the Inquirer
and prefers a formal charge before answering; Davide gives her
five days to reply to the motion to cite her to indirect contempt.
- 10th prosecution
witness Annie Ngo says the Yolando Ricaforte accounts plus the
interest amounted to P217 million; she claims Ricaforte was allowed
to open several accounts in several branches because these are
within vicinity of her residential and office addresses.
- 11th witness
Edelquinn Nantes, also of Equitable-PCI claims Ricaforte still
has more than P6 million in an account, which was frozen by the
bank on advice of the legal counsel.
- Ricaforte
was top depositor and was considered a valued client by the bank's
Timog branch; Nantes and other officials were surprised by Ricaforte,
who was a walk-in client but opened accounts in millions of pesos.
- Witness
Luis Singson takes the witness stand again to nail Estrada on
Article 2: graft and corruption. Claims Estrada asked for P130
million from the P200- million fund released to Ilocos Sur as
share of the tobacco excise tax.
- Singson
also claims First Lady Loi Ejercito and son Jose "Jinggoy"
Estrada were aware of the cash delivery; JV Ejercito, along with
several high-ranking government officials, reportedly called on
him to ask for settlement.
Day
8 highlights
Dec. 18, 2000
-
Senator-judge
Tessie Oreta moves to cite Rep. Clavel Asas-Martinez in
contempt for statements that appeared in a national paper.
- Impeachment
presiding officer Hilario Davide Jr. defers making his order for
the prosecution to open the sealed envelope containing the details
of the "Jose Valhalla" account until today, Tuesday.
- Broadcast
journalist Jay Sonza, the ninth witness, testifies that President
Estrada confirmed being offered P200 million in jueteng money
and that he later knew that this was deposited in a bank account
after his counsel, Edward Serapio, accepted it.
- Equitable
PCI Bank first vice president Annie Ngo recalls how Yolanda Ricaforte
opened several accounts in six bank branches and deposited about
P200 million in eight months.
Day
7 highlights
Dec. 15,
2000
-
Star witness, Ilocos Sur Gov. Luis Singson, claimed that
Guia Gomez and JV Ejercito witnessed one of the deliveries
of jueteng money to President Estrada.
-
A P2-million check issued by Singson for Estrada was endorsed
by Joelle Pelaez, one of the Presidents alleged mistresses.
-
A black bag, allegedly used to deliver P5 million in cash,
was presented to the impeachment tribunal.
-
Chief Justice Hilario Davide Jr. allowed the opening of
the sealed envelope containing bank records of an account
belonging to either Jose Valhalla or Jose Velarde, although
this is still subject to the possibility of a dissenting
opinion by administration senators.
-
Davide allowed depositions to be taken for some 30 bank
accounts, which will reportedly lead to the President.
Day
6 highlights
Dec. 14,
2000
-
Ilocos
Sur Gov. Luis Singson says President Estrada stopped jueteng
operations because he (the President) will get more, or
about P165 million a month, from Bingo 2-Ball.
-
Singson said the President's sons, Jinggoy and JV Secretaries
Edgardo Angara, Alfredo Lim, Zamora, Mark Jimenez and Atong
Ang were among those who tried to talk him out of his decision
to tell the public about Estrada's involvement in jueteng.
-
Singson quoted Lim as saying: "Ibintang na lang ang
lahat kay Atong Ang. Iligtas natin ang Presidente."
(Let's blame it all on Atong Ang, but save the President.)
-
In a meeting with him and Dante Tan, Singson said the President
told them to shift to another game, Bingo 2-Ball to give
the scheme some "semblance of legality."
-
Ma. Carmencita Itchon told the impeachment tribunal that
she helped Singson count and prepare jueteng money for delivery
to the President. The money was placed in a black bag.
-
Itchon
said Yolanda Ricaforte, using a cell phone bought by the
firm Fontainbleau, called Malacanang 21 times and Jinggoy
Estrada 20 times.
-
Singson
said Estrada owned Fontainbleau, but had ownership of the
firm placed in the name of a lawyer-friend.
-
Chief
Justice Hilario Davide Jr. deferred ruling on whether the
"Valhalla" bank account records with Equitable
PCI Bank can be admitted as evidence.
-
House Speaker Arnulfo Fuentebella sent the Senate president
a letter, stating that the House of Representatives did
not authorize the prosecution to let private prosecutors
participate in the hearings.
Day
5 highlights
Dec. 13,
2000
-
Witness
Maria Carmencita Itchon identified officials of the firm
that was supposedly controlled by Estrada's friends, including
Jesus "Bong" Pineda.
-
She identified Yolando Ricaforte as the President's auditor
for the jueteng collections.
-
Private prosecutors took an active participation in the
proceedings as "agents" of the impeachment prosecutors,
a move that drew objections from the defense and provoked
a long argument.
-
Presiding Officer Chief Justice Hilario Davide Jr. allowed
private prosecutors to do the presentation, because of the
claim that the panel of 11 prosecutors has all the power
to hire private lawyers.
-
Witness Luis Singson claimed it was President Estrada who
started the collections; he came in only after it became
too obvious for Jesus "Bong" Pineda to deliver
the money to the President.
-
He presented a P1.8-million check, which was dishonored
by a bank, and a P5-million check to prove that Estrada
really received the collections from jueteng operations.
However, it could not be determined who cashed the checks.
-
Discrepancies in the summations in the alleged ledgers were
noted.
Day
4 highlights
Dec. 12,
2000
-
Prosecution witness Francisco Yap Jr. said all six checks
are cashier's checks payable either to cash or bearer, endorsed
on the same day, coming from the same bank and all of them
are in substantial amounts - P11 million, P7 million, P77
million, P91 million and P3 million.
-
The transcript of President Estrada's admission that he
was offered P200 million in jueteng money before an association
of foreign journalists was presented as an exhibit.
-
Equitable PCI Bank Vice President Ceferino Ang refused to
disclose information that would help facilitate the hearing
for lack of depositor's consent, a move described by Prosecutor
Joker Arroyo as stonewalling.
-
Defense counsel Andres Narvasa objects to the manner the
prosecution is taking oral deposition from bank officials.
He claimed the defense panel was not informed about it.
-
Senator-juror Teofisto Guingona had an argument with Narvasa
for saying the prosecution should implement the mandate
of the court.
-
Presiding Judge Davide says documents from Equitable Bank
vice president should be diverted to the court in a sealed
envelope to be delivered in today's proceedings.
-
He ordered vice president of Equitable PCIBank Ang to show
cause why he should not be held in contempt for refusing
to comply with the subpoena.
-
Senator-judge John Osmeña requests the court to produce
a videotape of an ABS-CBN program - Philippine Times - aired
Monday, Dec. 11. Senator-judge Osmena says a member of the
prosecution made derogatory remarks against the defense
during the show. He calls for contempt of court on the member
of the prosecution who made those remarks.
Day
3 highlights
Dec. 11,
2000
-
Prosecution
presents Francisco Yap Jr., manager of the Philippine Clearing
House Corp. testified that the six checks, worth P200 million,
were encashed in different PCI Equitable Bank branches.
The checks were presented for clearing by the PCI Equitable
Bank Makati. These were microfilmed before these were sent
back to the drawee bank.
-
Prosecution continued its direct examination of Emma Lim.
She said she delivered P5 million to Malacanang in 1999,
on orders of her employer, Gov. Chavit Singson. The President's
secretary, whom she identified only as Malou, received the
money.
- She denied
that she was specifically told that the money (she collected
on several occasions) was from jueteng and for President Estrada.
-
On cross-examination, Estelito Mendoza zeroed in on her
poor memory for important dates e.g., the year she became
SK chairperson, the date she delivered the jueteng tong'
collections to Malacanang.
Day
2 highlights
Dec. 8, 2000
-
Defense
cross examined Lastimoso and presented a memoranda issued
by the latter regarding an all out war against illegal gambling
including jueteng in Luzon.
- Lastimoso
in another affidavit clarified that the President's order
for him to go easy on jueteng was merely his interpretation
and that he was not directly ordered by the President to do
so.
- Prosecution
presents Anton Prieto, Presidential assistant for Bicol affairs.
Prosecution
gathers specimen signatures from Prieto following the latter's
denial of a cheque from PNB Naga.
Prosecution
presents Emma Lim, secretary of Governor Singson. Highlights
of her testimony:
Day
1 highlights
DEC. 7, 2000
(Start
of the impeachment trial)
-
Prosecution
in their opening statement called Estrada a thief while his
lawyers likens him to Caesar. Prosecution accuses Estrada
of violating his oath of office "regularly, like clockwork."
- Prosecutors
accused Estrada of keeping a secret bank account under a false
name, which he used to hide his ownership of firms not listed
in his statement of assets.
- Rep.
Joker Arroyo showed the senators a check for P142 million
that carried the signature of one "Jose Valhallia."
It bore similarities to the signature of President Estrada
as shown on all peso bills. Arroyo claimed that this check,
with a face value of P142 million, was deposited to the account
of Jose Yulo, a close Estrada associate. Yulo, in turn, funded
Saint Peter's Holdings, which acquired an P86-million property
in New Manila on Oct. 1, 1999.
- Former
chief justice Andres Narvasa, the first to speak for the defense,
and fellow-defense lawyer Estelito Mendoza said what the prosecutors
presented "was not the truth, not the facts, but what
they propose to prove."
- "If
I were one of the prosecutors, I would say that the proof
has to be not just beyond reasonable doubt but of absolute
certainty, if the prosecution really has incontrovertible
proof," said Mendoza.
- Narvasa,
compared his client to Roman emperor Julius Caesar and urged
the senators not to "assassinate" him. Caesar was
assassinated after being betrayed by his adviser and best
friend Brutus.
- Prosecution
presented their first witness, former PNP Chief Roberto Lastimoso,
who testified that he was instructed by President Estrada
to coordinate with Ilocos Governor Luis "Chavit"
Singson regarding the jueteng operations.
- Prosecution
called on Yolanda Ricaforte to submit copy of the controversial
ledger which reportedly contains the jueteng collections from
various provinces for President Estrada.
[
T o p
]
|